BrightLocal's 2026 Small Business Marketing Report found that owners underrate Google: only 22% named it as a top-two source of new customers, while 71% of consumers used Google during their last local search. The same survey shows nearly half of small businesses sit below the review count many customers want, and many haven't checked whether AI tools mention them.
Below: the findings worth acting on, what the study can't tell you, and a self-check you can run this week.
Who ran the study, and how much weight should it get?
Treat it as a good read on direction, not on exact percentages. BrightLocal, a company that sells local SEO software, published the report on October 21, 2026. It surveyed 1,002 US owners of locally operated businesses with 1 to 50 employees, all of whom make or share marketing decisions.
A few limits are worth knowing before you act on any single number:
- BrightLocal hasn't published the exact question wording, and the report says both "1,000" and "1,002" owners in different places.
- Owner answers are beliefs, not tracked results. "Social media brings us the most customers" is what owners think, not what their analytics show.
- The consumer numbers come from separate BrightLocal surveys, such as its Consumer Search Behavior study (1,227 US consumers, July 2026). Comparing owners with consumers shows a direction, not an exact gap.
Where do owners think new customers come from?
Mostly word of mouth and social media. Asked to pick the two channels that brought the most new customers in the last 12 months, owners put Google joint fourth (22%), tied with their own website and just behind AI tools.
Owners also credit AI tools slightly more than Google. The next section shows why that's worth checking before you shift budget toward AI.
Part of this is how people remember a sale. A customer who heard about you from a neighbor, then searched your name on Google to find your number, gets filed under word of mouth. Google did the last step, but the owner is likely to remember the neighbor. If you don't ask new customers how they found you, or track calls from your Google listing, you can't tell which one actually brought them in.
What do customers actually do when they search?
Most start on Google and many use more than one channel. In BrightLocal's July 2026 consumer study, 61% started their last local search on Google (52% on Google Search and 9% on Google Maps), 71% used Google at some point, and 75% used more than one channel.
AI tools are in the mix but rarely work alone: 23% of consumers used AI in their last local search, yet only 8% started there. Of those who did start with an AI tool, 43% went on to Google and only 2% used AI alone. Only 18% of AI users felt ready to contact a business the AI recommended without checking further, and for many, Google is where that checking happens.
Where are the biggest gaps between owners and customers?
Five stand out: Google's role, review counts, review replies, profile upkeep and AI answers. The table puts each owner finding next to the matching customer data.
| Topic | What owners said | What the data shows | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22% name Google as a top-two source of new customers | 71% used Google during their last local search | Your listing is often the last stop before a call, even when it isn't the first | |
| Reviews | 47% have fewer than 20 Google reviews | 47% won't use a business with fewer than 20 reviews | Nearly half of businesses fall below a bar nearly half of customers hold |
| Review replies | 51% respond to reviews | 89% expect owners to respond; 42% are unlikely to use a business that ignores reviews | Replies are a cheap way to stand out |
| Google Business Profile | 85% have one; 35% say they keep an active presence on it | AI answers about local businesses cite Google Business Profile more than any other source | A profile you set up years ago and left alone is doing less than it could |
| AI answers | 54% checked and are confident they appear; 21% think they probably do but haven't checked | AI recommendations changed across repeated prompts in BrightLocal's tests, and only 18% of AI users would contact a recommended business without checking further | One check isn't enough; the answer can differ each time |
How many reviews do small businesses really have?
Not many: 47% have fewer than 20 Google reviews, 28% have 21 to 50, and 16% have more than 50. Owners who regularly ask are slightly more likely to have more than 50 reviews (19%, against 15% of those who don't).
Industry matters. Food and drink businesses are least likely to be under 20 reviews (35%), while professional services have the lowest reply rate (45%). If you're in professional services, replying to every review is an easy way to stand out.
Google's rules for asking are simple. You can send customers a Google review link or QR code, and Google prohibits offering incentives such as discounts or free services in exchange for reviews. Our breakdown of BrightLocal's 2026 review survey covers how many reviews a month it takes to catch up.
Are small businesses ready for AI search?
Most say they're working on it, but many haven't checked the basics. 65% of owners say they are actively working on AI search visibility, 13% plan to start, and 7% want to but don't know where to start.
Confidence runs ahead of checking. 54% say they've checked and are confident their business shows up in AI results, but 21% believe they probably do without having looked. BrightLocal also analyzed 200,000 AI prompts across 1,300 locations on ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews, and found the recommendations weren't consistent when the same prompt was repeated.
The sources those AI tools cited are familiar. Google Business Profile accounted for 28.63% of citations, Yelp for 9.53% and Facebook for 2.23%. That suggests the work that helps you on Google, a complete profile and steady reviews, also feeds AI answers. Our guide to getting your business mentioned by ChatGPT walks through the rest.
What stops owners from doing more marketing?
The top answer is that it feels too technical (28%), and budget comes last (19%). Next is "we already get enough customers" (26%), then "not convinced it makes a difference" (25%) and "don't know enough about how it works" (24%). Lack of time, not knowing where to start and past efforts that didn't work each got 23%.
That fits who's doing the work: 85% of owners take primary responsibility for marketing decisions. If you're one of them, the useful takeaway is that the biggest gaps in this report aren't technical at all. Asking for reviews, replying to them and keeping your Google listing current take minutes, not skills.
What should a small business do with these findings?
Run a short self-check against the gaps above, then fix the ones you fail. Most take under an hour; asking for reviews is a habit, not a one-time task.
- Count your Google reviews. If you're under 20, set up a review link or QR code and ask every happy customer this month.
- Reply to every review from the last three months. Short and specific beats long and generic. Google checks replies before they show, which usually takes up to 10 minutes but can take up to 30 days.
- Update your Google Business Profile. Check hours, services and photos, and add something new. 72% of owners say they updated theirs in the last three months, though only 35% say they keep an "active presence" on it. BrightLocal hasn't published the questions, so those likely measure different things. Either way, a profile untouched for months is behind most. Our Google Business Profile guide lists what to fill in.
- Ask new customers how they found you. Add "How did you hear about us?" to your intake form or first call, and note when the answer is "a friend, then I looked you up." That's word of mouth and Google working together.
- Check AI answers more than once. Use the tip above. Separately, see where you show up on Google Maps from different spots in your area with our free local SERP checker.
If you'd rather hand this off, our local SEO service covers Google Business Profile and reviews, and our AI search service covers how AI tools describe your business.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do owners credit AI tools more than Google?
The report doesn't say. Owners may remember an AI recommendation as the start of a sale, while the Google search that followed goes unnoticed; only 8% of consumers in BrightLocal's July 2026 study started a local search with AI.
Does this survey apply to businesses outside the US?
Not directly. The owner survey and the July 2026 consumer study were both US only, so treat the numbers as a rough guide elsewhere.
Where can I read the full report?
BrightLocal publishes it free in four chapters, starting from its Small Business Marketing Report 2026 page.
